How Reliability is Measured

Consumer Reports surveys thousands of members annually about the appliances they own. For ranges, they ask whether the product has broken or stopped working properly within the first 5 years of ownership. The resulting data covers 17 major gas range brands and 13 electric range brands, drawn from 50,329 ranges purchased between 2013 and 2023.

This is the most comprehensive reliability dataset available on stoves — far more reliable than individual Amazon reviews, which can be gamed or skewed by recency bias. When Consumer Reports says a brand has reliability problems, it means thousands of real owners reported real breakdowns.

The Most Reliable Gas Range Brands

1. LG — Most Reliable Overall

LG earns the highest predicted reliability marks for gas ranges in Consumer Reports’ surveys — one of only two brands to earn top marks in their gas range category. LG gas ranges combine strong burner performance with above-average long-term durability. Their sealed burner design and electronic ignition systems have shown low failure rates across thousands of ownership years of data.

2. GE and GE Profile

GE and its premium GE Profile sub-brand consistently rank among the most reliable gas range manufacturers. GE’s wide distribution network also means parts availability and service technician access are better than most brands — an important practical consideration when a repair is needed. Consumer Reports recommends the GE Profile PGS960YPFS as their top-rated gas range model overall.

3. Bosch

Bosch earns strong reliability marks for both gas and electric ranges. German engineering and quality control translate into below-average repair rates. Bosch ranges tend to be priced at the mid-to-upper end of the market, but the reliability data justifies the premium for buyers prioritising long-term cost of ownership.

The Most Reliable Electric Range Brands

1. Frigidaire — Top Electric Reliability

Frigidaire earns top marks for predicted reliability in electric smoothtop ranges — one of their most consistent strengths despite middling owner satisfaction scores. If long-term durability is your primary concern in an electric range, Frigidaire’s track record is hard to argue with. The brand lags on design and features compared to GE or LG, but breaks down less often.

2. LG

LG repeats at the top of the electric category as well, combining excellent reliability with strong owner satisfaction scores. LG electric ranges with induction capability are particularly well-regarded — Consumer Reports cites LG induction ranges as among the best performers for both speed and reliability.

Brands to Approach with Caution

Samsung

Samsung’s kitchen appliances have consistently scored below average for predicted reliability in Consumer Reports’ surveys across multiple years. This is particularly striking given Samsung’s strong brand recognition and premium retail pricing. Samsung gas and electric ranges show higher repair rates within 5 years of ownership than the category average. Their owner satisfaction scores are also below average.

KitchenAid

KitchenAid ranges are positioned as premium appliances and priced accordingly — which makes their below-average reliability scores all the more surprising. Consumer Reports’ data shows KitchenAid ranges have higher-than-average problem rates within the first 5 years. Buyers drawn to KitchenAid’s aesthetics and brand reputation should be aware that the reliability data does not support the premium.

Does Price Predict Reliability?

Definitively not. Consumer Reports’ own engineers have stated: “Price is no indicator of performance.” In their testing, some ranges at $1,000 outperform models at $5,000. Pro-style ranges, which carry the highest price tags, often underperform conventional models in both lab tests and reliability surveys. The reliability leaders — LG, GE, Bosch, Frigidaire — are all mid-range brands, not luxury manufacturers.

Gas vs Electric vs Induction — Which is Most Reliable?

Across all brands, induction ranges tend to have fewer mechanical failures than gas ranges — they have fewer moving parts (no igniters, no gas valves, no burner ports to clog). Electric smoothtops sit between the two. However, brand matters more than fuel type: an LG gas range is more reliable than a Samsung induction range, regardless of the technology advantage of induction.

Our Recommended Picks

Based on the reliability data above, here are our top picks available on Amazon — both from brands with proven reliability track records:

Frequently Asked Questions